Australian PC User contributing editor
Five things Ubuntu really needs
There have been a couple of interesting Diggs this morning about features “Ubuntu really needs”. The first post seemed a bit ditzy and the second for the most part was on the money – Ubuntu already has a truckload of features and most things it doesn’t have by default can be installed from the Ubuntu repositories via Synaptic or (my personal favourite) via Terminal and apt-get.
I’ve been using Linux for about two years and I’ve tried out various shades available on the web. I’ve even built a number of distros for Australian PC User magazine under the “UserOS” banner, the most recent being UserOS Netbook 8.10 Beta, an operating system designed for netbook computers.
We can spend out time arguing about whether Ubuntu really needs a weather control on the desktop, but that’s like arguing over whether Windows really needs User Account Control (UAC). I figure there are still some “bigger-picture” things Ubuntu (and more probably Linux) could use help from all of us on.
1) More encouragement for beginners
Linux is a great operating system. It’s organised, it’s quick and it has a growing list of applications longer than my… arm. Okay, longer than your arm. But I’ve seen too many stories and comments hitting the web of “know-it-alls” attacking newbies for not knowing everything there is to know about Linux. I’ve read comments from Linux hardheads giving grief to users looking for neat graphical user interface (GUI) to achieve some task.
To some, it’s a case if you don’t use Terminal, then you almost have no right to use Linux. And that’s completely bloody stupid because a) everyone starts out knowing nothing about Linux and 2) if Terminal was the answer to everything, we’d never have got stuck with Windows!
Too many experienced Linux users come across as grumpy old men who seem to dismiss anyone who’s learned and blogged something they’ve known since Noah was in short pants. Sure, if it’s wrong say so but it’s just as important we encourage new Linux users. If they find out we’re all a bunch of narky prats full of their own source code, why would they bother continuing? It’s just as easy to try Mac OS X as it is Linux…
Rather than grumbling about it, experienced Linux users should be helping to feed their vast knowledge back into the community and helping those who’ve just begun their journey into Linux.
2) Better support from big name brands
Okay for those of you living in the US, this is less of an issue but in Australia, finding brand-name systems with any version of Linux preinstalled isn’t easy. Dell has one or two but you can’t even buy an Inspiron Mini 9 here with Ubuntu installed. The same goes for Toshiba’s NB100. Both have special LPIA versions of Ubuntu for their US and UK models – but not in Australia.
The big-name brands need to be lobbied to provide equal services to other parts of the world – there’s no reason for Dell not to offer its Ubuntu versions of the Mini 9 in Australia. We can read you know…
3) Improved hardware driver support
Driver software is always an issue for Linux. Thankfully, this is improving but again, it’s still an ugly issue in Australia, particularly when it comes to modems. Local telco Optus has 3G modems available as part of a wireless plan – the modem comes with driver software for Windows and Mac OS X. Does it come with drivers for Linux? Nope.
Graphics cards are another issue but thankfully, this one has improved markedly in recent times.
Ubuntu’s lead times mean that it can be a while before hardware device drivers are updated so it’s not always the best option, particularly if you’re trying to run the latest notebook or 3G hardware.
4) Better netbook/notebook support
Yep, this is coming in 9.04 and there’s already Ubuntu Netbook Remix but it’s not exactly a simple job for newbies to install and setup. Having developed UserOS Netbook 8.10 Beta for the March 2009 issue of Australian PC User, getting WiFi and webcam drivers built and installed into the OS certainly wasn’t a job I could recommend a Linux newbie have a go at.
In the end, I spent several hours just getting these features working for the MSI Wind U100 and the Asus Eee PC 901/1000 range. It required source-code capture, compiling and installation. Yes, there are various spin-off operating systems built on Ubuntu that now offer built-in driver support but that’s more a case of third-party developers doing the job after Canonical release a particular version, which means an even longer wait. Netbooks have already been around for near-on 18 months and Ubuntu will only just get serious about them in 9.04 come April 30.
5) More supporters introducing it to their friends
There have been few things to advance the cause of Linux more than the release of Windows Vista. For better or worse, many users saw Vista as a right-royal-stuff-up from the start. In practice, I haven’t found it that bad but the majority of the blogosphere and media world has panned it mercilessly. For sure, User Account Control deserved to be mocked by Apple in its ads but the very fact Apple featured it and other Windows “features” in its ads showed that even Apple thought Windows had now become almost a parody of itself.
With the economy tanking, jobs becoming scarce, the time is right for Linux to become the low-cost way for everyone to keep up with what’s happening in technology, particularly the internet. The internet no longer relies on a computer with a specific operating system. So instead of hanging around with Windows XP alone, users could be introduced to a 2009 operating system in Ubuntu without having to cough up the price of another Microsoft operating system. Or PC.
Ubuntu doesn’t really need more tricks like weather on the desktop. It’s been done. It doesn’t need Mac OS X-like docks. It doesn’t need a whole bunch of things.
What it does need is people like you and me showing it to our friends, helping those new Linux users find their feet and providing a constructive community that shares its knowledge to make Linux (and Ubuntu in particular) easier to use for everyone.
Similar Posts:
- The one thing stopping Linux from greatness
- YouGrab 3 now available – Windows, Linux and Mac OS X – August 2010 issue
- UserOS Netbook 8.10 Beta arrives in March 2009 PC User
- New UserOS column – starting May 2010 issue of Australian PC User
- Ubuntu & Xubuntu 8.10 are out!
- Linux/Ubuntu’s other problem – dial-up modem support
- Next UserOS operating system to have 3G support
- USerOS Extreme 9.04 – out now on the October 2009 issue of PC User
- Vista vs XP vs Linux – my three-month test
- UserOS Ultra 9.10 – out next week in PC User April 2010 issue
Social Media buttons brought to you by S-ButtonZ (WordPress Plugin)
| Print article | This entry was posted by Darren Yates on March 10, 2009 at 10:16 am, and is filed under Linux, What the... ?. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |


about 1 year ago
well,
about the 4 point, i do not agree because if you try simplis.org or vixta.org they have been made for work “out of the box” in NetBooks, i.e., AcerOne, eeePC, Dell 9, HP mini 1000 ….
Reply
darren Reply:
March 11th, 2009 at 6:49 am
Yes, but I did actually mention there are other distros that specifically work with netbooks. The problem is Ubuntu with its long lead development times.
Reply
about 1 year ago
Your point 2 is bogus. You don’t need special drivers for USB modems. It is a standard part of the operating system. I have used 3G devices in both USB and PCMCIA form factors from Sprint and the fact that they don’t provide any Linux software made no difference. I just insert the cards and the system detected both as a USB modem and I just set up a PPP connection using the detected device.
Reply
darren Reply:
March 11th, 2009 at 6:47 am
Wow, that’s nice for you. However, Sprint is not available in Australia… So my point isn’t quite as bogus as you suggest.
Reply
Andrew Reply:
March 16th, 2009 at 9:28 am
Darren,
I use Three’s 3g modem E180G without any problems with ubuntu 8.10.
Reply
Darren Yates Reply:
March 16th, 2009 at 12:28 pm
Andrew, which bundle deal does it come with?
about 1 year ago
So basically all you are saying is hardware is an issue… make plug and play.
Reply
about 1 year ago
Seriously people. Did any of your READ his post?
aspantos: This post isn’t about what Linux needs. He’s specifically talking about Ubuntu. He even addresses the spin off distros and the fact that they have a release delay is his complaint. So listing other distros doesn’t really apply to a post about Ubuntu.
txtechdog: You mention Sprint. That is delightful that Sprint provides linux compatible phones. I must send them a congratulations about that. However that has NO bearing on someone in Australia. The fact that their service provider does not use a modem which has linux drivers is not only believable, but a real issue. You’re response of “Well MY hardware works, I don’t see what you’re problem is” betrays a seriously self centered world view. Especially if we’re talking about the hardware used by a service provider for a major region making sure it’s supported is something worth spending development time on.
wren: make plug and play??? Yes because end users make hardware and drivers plug and play. You must send me a description of this voodoo ritual you perform over your hardware to achieve this magic. It would make my life so very much easier.
I love linux, and I wish I could get more people to use it, but the attitudes you three have demonstrated not only alienates new users, but it’s frequency among developers is exactly why the areas where linux needs to most improve it doesn’t.
Reply
about 1 year ago
Another thing I think Ubuntu needs cleaner icons. I think the icons look childish. Windows and MAC have great looking icons. That’s where they get it right: an attractive interface.
Just my humble opinion.
Reply
about 1 year ago
@Mike yes they could touch up some of the icons.
I agree with GUI’s. Why can’t some folk get it through their heads that not everyone is a technical user. A doctor or lawyer should not have to play with CLI if they don’t want to. That being said….there really aren’t that many things that require CLI unlike what FUD spreaders would have you believe.
The one place I have a problem is with mounting shares. Editing fstab is unacceptable for a desktop. I now use pyNeighborhood and before that I was about to develop the exact same application for myself. It could still use some improvement however.
Also Ubuntu could use some sort of tutorial app that runs with new installs to help new users find new things and tell them about features. This could even help on upgrades as I sometimes forget what new features to look for and have to go look them up to try them out. They should be advertised somehow within the OS.
Reply
about 1 year ago
1) More encouragement for beginners
Good point, and its something that is already being worked on heavily within the Ubuntu community with the Ubuntu Beginners Team who’s mandate is to provide support to new users through the Ubuntu Forums, Launchpad, and IRC. They will shortly be also providing courses to teach new and intermediate users functions of Ubuntu.
Reply
Darren Yates Reply:
March 16th, 2009 at 9:01 am
That’s good to hear, but there are still some sections of the wider Linux community who really need to pull their heads in when it comes to some of the newbie comments that I’ve read.
Reply
Matthew Lye Reply:
March 16th, 2009 at 9:16 am
The sad thing is they probably don’t realize that they are one of the main reasons new users go back to Windows. They say they support Linux but drive people away.
Reply
Darren Yates Reply:
March 16th, 2009 at 12:30 pm
Yep, if Linux is to flourish, it needs to stop being the geek’s operating system and needs to become a general-purpose OS. Yeah, I know it is for many people but when you get boofheads telling newbies “ha-ha you’re a newbie and don’t know as much as I do!”, that does no-one any good at all. What Ubuntu is proposing is a great idea and hopefully, it will help overcome some of those clowns and help new users see that Linux in general and Ubuntu in particular are not that scary.
about 1 year ago
I miss “proper IPv6-support”.
Reply